I'm looking to create a comma-separated list of values from a SQL Server 2005 table, just like in JanetOhara's question. I'm using a query similar to the one presented in techdo's answer to the question.
Everything is working, except the list of values is getting XML encoded. What should be:
Sports & Recreation,x >= y
Is instead returning as:
Sports & Recreation,x <= y
Is there a way to disable the XML character encoding when using "FOR XML" in SQL Server?
You just need to use the right options with FOR XML. Here's one approach that avoids encoding:
USE tempdb;
GO
CREATE TABLE dbo.x(y nvarchar(255));
INSERT dbo.x SELECT 'Sports & Recreation'
UNION ALL SELECT 'x >= y'
UNION ALL SELECT 'blat'
UNION ALL SELECT '<hooah>';
-- BAD:
SELECT STUFF((SELECT N',' + y
FROM dbo.x
FOR XML PATH(N'')),1, 1, N'');
-- GOOD:
SELECT STUFF((SELECT N',' + y
FROM dbo.x
FOR XML PATH,
TYPE).value(N'./text()[1]', N'nvarchar(max)'), 1, 1, N'');
GO
DROP TABLE dbo.x;
If you are on a newer version of SQL Server (2017+), you can use STRING_AGG() and not worry about XML at all:
SELECT STRING_AGG(y, N',') FROM dbo.x;
db<>fiddle demonstrating all three.
type and .value('.[1]',nvarchar(max)') worked perfectly. Thanks for the help.
',' + y to something else? The STUFF is used to strip off the first character, which should be a leading comma unless you changed the query in other ways.
value to be case-sensitive, it wouldn't recognise VALUE.You can also do this:
-- BAD:
SELECT STUFF((SELECT N',' + y
FROM dbo.x
FOR XML PATH(N'')),1, 1, N'');
-- GOOD:
SELECT STUFF((SELECT N',' + y
FROM dbo.x
FOR XML PATH(N''), TYPE).value('(./text())[1]','varchar(max)'),1, 1, N'');
See this post on Creating concatenated delimited string from a SQL result set and avoid character encoding when using “FOR XML PATH”
An alternate approach would be to rely on concatenation of characters (of course sql is not great with string operations as it is developed to work with set theory)
USE tempdb;
GO
CREATE TABLE dbo.x ( y NVARCHAR(255) );
INSERT dbo.x
SELECT 'Sports & Recreation'
UNION ALL
SELECT 'x >= y'
UNION ALL
SELECT 'blat'
UNION ALL
SELECT '<hooah>';
DECLARE @delimitedText varchar(max)
SET @delimitedText=''
SELECT @delimitedText += CASE WHEN LEN(@delimitedText) > 0 THEN +','+ y ELSE y END
FROM dbo.x
SELECT @delimitedText
GO
DROP TABLE dbo.x;
GO
