12

I have a associative array

Array(
   [289] => Array(
    'name'=> 'One'
   ),
   [292] => Array(
    'name'=> 'One'
   ),
   [290] => Array(
    'name'=> 'One'
   )
)

After i use json_encode on this array. The keys are sorted, although i get it as JSON object.

Is there way to prevent this behaviour?

3
  • Looks like php json_encode is return the correct order. Its the browser which is sorting the object. Commented Jan 19, 2014 at 11:59
  • Are you sure? For me PHP's json_encode sorts the array, rather than the browsers. Commented Dec 10, 2015 at 5:46
  • Check out JSON_FORCE_OBJECT in php.net/manual/en/json.constants.php - I had an associative array with numeric ID's as the keys and it was converting them as a non-associative array Commented May 24, 2016 at 2:30

2 Answers 2

6

there is no standard that says it has to be in a certain order.

See this for a related question: How do you stop Chrome and Opera sorting JSON objects by Index ASC?

note: we're talking about a PHP function, but the result is basically javascript, so the statement about the non-existing standard applies as well.

btw: I have tested it with the following code. PHP itself doesnt seem to sort the array, firefox doesn't as well (according to the firebug console).

<pre>
<?php
    $array = array();
    $array[289] = array('name'=>'One');
    $array[292] = array('name'=>'One');
    $array[290] = array('name'=>'One');
    print_r($array);
    $string = json_encode($array);
    print_r($string);
?>
</pre>
<script>
    var foo = <?=$string?>;
    console.log(foo);
</script>
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

4 Comments

This is the correct answer. If you want your own order, give the array your own index.
+1 , for the right thing.
Yes, its browser which is culprit
Note: firefox will sort keys if the keys are numeric and under something like 500. Javascript objects are not guaranteed to have ordering, this is a mistake a lot of people, most languages associative arrays are not ordered by entry. If you want order, use ordered arrays. bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=865760
-4

Try this:

    $ar = array();
    $ar[1] = array('1'=>'one');
    $ar[2] = array('2'=>'two');
    $ar[3] = array('3'=>'three');
    print_r($ar);
    $str= json_encode($ar);
    print_r($str);

it should work, at-least helps me !

2 Comments

It doesn't work like that, i have a non associative array where i need to preserve the keys but order alphabetichally by Value, using Asort it gets ordered properly but when sent to using json_encode the object gets sorted by key again
That's exactly the same problem I'm having, been looking for a solution everywhere but no luck yet.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.