I don't understand how all those f() function work, can someone explain why it prints two '1', I know it prints '1' for every '()' after f(f), but I don't know why.
function f(y) {
let x = y;
var i = 0;
return () => {
console.log(++i);
return x(y);
};
}
f(f)()();And why does the 'i' doesn't increase?
Thank you.
function f(y) {
let x = y;
var i = 0;
return () => {
console.log(++i);
return x(y);
};
}
f(f)()();
is equivalent to
function f() {
var i = 0;
return () => {
console.log(++i);
return f();
};
}
const t1 = f();
const t2 = t1();
t2();
is equivalent to
function f() {
var i = 0;
return () => {
console.log(++i);
};
}
const t1 = f();
t1();
const t2 = f();
t2();
If you did call each of t1 or t2 multiple times instead of just once, you'd increment the i from the respective closure some more. But if you instead just chain them, they call f again and initialise a new var i = 0 for a different closure.
First, the f(y) function essentially calling y onto itself. Executing f(y) would return a new function, which when executed, would execute x(y) and return the results.
To reduce the confusion, it's just calling f(f) for each f() you executed in this example, as x === y and y === f. The important part of why i never seems to increase, is that every execution creates a new i.
What happens in behind are:
f(f)()();
// is same as
const f1 = f(f);
const f2 = f1();
const f3 = f2();
// f(f) would execute first, and returns () => {
// console.log(++i);
// return x(y); // which is same as returning f(f) in this example
// }
Notice that executing f(f) returns x(y) which x(y) seems to be equal to f(f). Seems as it is similar in code, but different instance. Another point is that i was never carried to this new function, nor are shared to the other instances. Each f(f) creates a new i, never passed to the next function.
Let's name the function at line 4 , function A.
return result of function f() is function A.(at line 4 you define a function, you don't call it.)
the body of A is gonna be this and since you use those variables in an inner function, they are not gonna be exposed(i = 0, x = y = f ):
function A(){
console.log(++i);
return x(y);
First parenthesis: A() prints a '1' and returns result of f(f) which is function A.(the first i is exposed and a new i is created)
Second parenthesis : A is executed like I said and return another A, since there are no any parenthesis left, there is no more call.
You declare in f always a new i.
Instead, you could store the count into a property of the function itself.
function f(y) {
let x = y;
f.i = f.i || 0;
return () => {
console.log(++f.i);
return x(y);
};
}
f(f)()()();
x ≡ y ≡ f. And you're calling each() => { console.log(++i); … }that is created by them only once.