Adding elements of different type to arraylist

You should create a named constructor (from Effective Java J.Bloch) for your Card class and override equals and hashCode for it like this:

class Card {
    private String valueAsString;

    /*your code here*/
    
    public static Card of(String valueAsString) {
         Card card = /*create your card here*/
         card.valueAsString = valueAsString;
         return card;
    }

    @Override
    public boolean equals(Object other) {
         /*another part of equals*/
         return Objects.equals(valueAsString, other.valueAsString);
    }

    @Override
    public int hashCode() {
         return Objects.hash(valueAsString);
    }
}

With that named constructor you can just do the following thing:

    if (player1Hand.contains(Card.of(split[2]))) {
         /*do something*/
    }

The explanation: as soon as ArrayList uses an equals method to compare elements in the array you need to define it properly. Besides, a named constructor helps you to create a placeholder object based on value of split[2]. With this two steps you will be able to use contains and it will work as you want to. Why should you override a hashCode too? You should do it, because there is an informal rule that you should always override equals and hashCode like a pair, because they have to do it's stuff with the same set of fields.