For loop with if conditional statement

Question

I am trying to understand why first code run only once vs second code is running until it checks all the items in the list.

1.

def get_word_over_10_char(list_of_words):
    for word in list_of_words:
        if len(word) > 10:
            return word
        else:
            return ""

for word in list_of_words:
    if len(word) > 10:
        return word
return ''

word_list = ['soup', 'parameter', 'intuition', 'house-maker', 'fabrication']

Trying to return a word if length is more than 10, and return empty string if less than equal to 10.

Could you share the entire function and the list to make your problem more clear? — Timo
– Timo, Commented Nov 25, 2022 at 20:54

Timo · Accepted Answer · 2022-11-25 20:53:03Z

1

How are the items in your list ordered? Because the when the return statement in a function is called, the function returns the argument and stops. In the first piece of code, either the return in the if clause or the else is called after the first item in list_of_words, so the function stops there. In the second piece of code, the return word statement is only called once a word longer than 10 characters is found. From how you describe the problem, I reckon that the last item in your list_of_words is longer than 10. So with the second piece of code, you notice that that word is not returned, while you do not notice the empty strings not being returned.

answered Nov 25, 2022 at 20:53

Timo

3771 silver badge11 bronze badges

Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.

2 Comments

user20602484 Over a year ago

Words are listed randomly. You are right it is only checking the first word in the list which are longer than 10 and code stops. It is not running again to check rest of words in the list, that is another issue.

user20602484 Over a year ago

word_list = ['soup', 'parameter', 'intuition', 'house-maker', 'fabrication']

Anton B · Accepted Answer · 2022-11-25 21:45:08Z

As Timo explained in his answer, function stops when you use return. In order to get all the elements with more than 10 characters, you need to create a list with these words before using return :

def get_word_over_10_char(list_of_words):
    more_than_10 = []
    for word in list_of_words:
        if len(word) > 10:
            more_than_10.append(word)
    if len(more_than_10)==0:
        return  "Nothing longer than 10"
    return more_than_10
        
word_list = ['soup', 'parameter', 'intuition', 'house-maker', 'fabrication']

print(get_word_over_10_char(word_list))

A more pythonic second version using list comprehension to create more_than_10:

def get_word_over_10_char_v2(list_of_words):
    more_than_10 = [word for word in list_of_words if len(word) > 10]
    if len(more_than_10)==0:
        return  "Nothing longer than 10"
    return more_than_10
        
word_list = ['soup', 'parameter', 'intuition', 'house-maker', 'fabrication']

print(get_word_over_10_char_v2(word_list))

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

For loop with if conditional statement

2 Answers 2

2 Comments

Comments

Your Answer

Hot Network Questions

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

2 Answers 2

2 Comments

Comments

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Related